Skip to content

Volunteer evaluations for nonprofits

By Scott Mackley, founder of performerborn. Updated .

Say a few thoughts about each volunteer and performerborn writes an evaluation that names what they did, what to keep doing and what’s next. The pages say Volunteer, not Employee, and your organization’s name goes at the top. About 3 minutes per person, checking included.

Write mine

From $18 per person, about 3 minutes each

Names and notes are deleted 30 days after your order is finished. Nothing is added beyond what you said.

Page 1 of a sample volunteer review for Gloria Bennett, Volunteer at Eastside Community Food Pantry, written with AI from invented notes
A finished sample review, written with AI from invented notes. See the notes.

How it works for volunteers

Choose Nonprofit as your business type and pick Volunteer review. Every design then prints Volunteer in the header, the comments box and the signature line. Staff at the same nonprofit can get an ordinary review in the same way.

Talk about what each volunteer did, with an example, one thing you’d like done differently, and what you’d like next, such as leading a shift. You check the review says what you meant, then approve it.

Rather fill it in yourself? Use our free performance review template, as Word or PDF.

Drafted with AI from your notes. You check it and approve it.

  • Name what they did, with an example: the shift they covered, the program they ran. Concrete feedback is easier to accept. How we do this
  • Keep it about the work, not the person. How we do this
  • Ask what they want next, and agree one clear next step. How we do this
  • Leave room for their side. Being heard matters to how people take any review. How we do this

A template you can copy

Free template

Free volunteer evaluation template

For a check-in with a volunteer at the end of a season or a year. It is as much about what they want next as about how it went.

Prefer a file? The general template is free as Word or PDF, on the template page.

Or have it written from what you say: say a few thoughts about each person, and performerborn writes the finished page for you to check.

Volunteer evaluation

Volunteer evaluation

Volunteer name:
Role or program:
Period:
Shifts or hours (if you track them):
Completed by:

WHAT THEY DID
What did they help with this season? Give an example.

THE DIFFERENCE IT MADE
What changed for the people you serve, or for the program?

ANYTHING TO DO DIFFERENTLY
Is there anything to change next time? What would help?

WHAT'S NEXT
Would they like a new role, more time, less time, or the same?

Is there any training they would like?

HOW WE CAN HELP
What will the organization do to support them?

VOLUNTEER COMMENTS
Anything the volunteer would like to add.

Volunteer signature and date:

Coordinator signature and date:

Sample evaluations

Each one is exactly what performerborn wrote with AI from the invented notes beside it, unedited.

Volunteer review for Gloria Bennett, Volunteer

Community food pantry · Eastside Community Food Pantry · written with AI from invented notes

What Paul said (95 words)

Gloria has been with us every Tuesday and Saturday this year and we honestly couldn't do it without her. She took over organizing the donation intake and sorting, and she set up a system with color-coded bins that cut sorting time almost in half. She's warm with the families who come in, never makes anyone feel rushed. She also trained six new volunteers. The one thing I'd love is for her to use the sign-up sheet, sometimes she just shows up and we're overstaffed. Next year I'd love for her to lead the Saturday shift.

The review shown here is what performerborn wrote with AI from these notes, unedited. The notes are invented, and so are Gloria’s name, the business and the manager.

Page 1 of a sample volunteer review for Gloria Bennett, Volunteer at Eastside Community Food Pantry, written with AI from invented notes
Page 1 of 2.See page 2
Read the text of this review

Page 1

ECF

Eastside Community Food Pantry

VOLUNTEER REVIEW

Check-in

VOLUNTEER

Gloria Bennett

ROLE

Volunteer

MANAGER

Paul Ortega, Volunteer Coordinator

REVIEW DATE

October 3, 2026

Gloria has been a consistent and invaluable volunteer this year, contributing every Tuesday and Saturday. She took initiative to organize donation intake and sorting with a color-coded bin system that cut sorting time nearly in half, trained six new volunteers, and consistently makes families feel welcome and unhurried.

CONTINUE

Donation sorting system The color-coded bin system Gloria set up cut sorting time nearly in half and keeps intake organized.

Welcoming families Gloria is warm with families and makes sure no one feels rushed.

Training volunteers Gloria trained six new volunteers this year.

START

Using the sign-up sheet Sign up for shifts in advance so Paul can balance staffing.

FOCUS UNTIL NEXT CHECK-IN

Use the sign-up sheet for every shift and continue building toward leading the Saturday shift next year.

Page 2

GLORIA'S COMMENTS

Volunteer signature and date

Manager signature and date

Written from Paul Ortega's notes with performerborn, edited and approved by Paul. Signing confirms it was discussed.

Annual review for Renee Thompson, Program Coordinator

Youth arts nonprofit · Canvas Kids Arts Collective · written with AI from invented notes

What Daniel said (84 words)

Renee has had a strong year. She coordinated our after-school art program across four sites and enrollment went from about ninety kids to a hundred and forty. She recruited and scheduled our teaching artists and kept everything running smoothly. Families and site partners love her. She also wrote the program report for our biggest grant renewal, which we got. Growth area is budget tracking, she needs to keep a closer eye on supply spending. Next year I'd like her to launch our summer camp.

The review shown here is what performerborn wrote with AI from these notes, unedited. The notes are invented, and so are Renee’s name, the business and the manager.

Page 1 of a sample annual review for Renee Thompson, Program Coordinator at Canvas Kids Arts Collective, written with AI from invented notes
Page 1 of 2.See page 2
Read the text of this review

Page 1

CKA

Canvas Kids Arts Collective

ANNUAL REVIEW

Performance Review

EMPLOYEE

Renee Thompson

ROLE

Program Coordinator

MANAGER

Daniel Ruiz, Executive Director

REVIEW PERIOD

2026

REVIEW DATE

October 3, 2026

OVERALL SUMMARY

Renee has had a strong year. She coordinated the after-school art program across four sites, grew enrollment significantly, maintained strong relationships with families and partners, and delivered key grant work. The main area to develop is budget tracking, particularly around supply spending.

KEY STRENGTHS

01

Program coordination

Renee coordinated the after-school art program across four sites and kept everything running smoothly throughout the year.

02

Program growth

Renee grew enrollment from about ninety kids to a hundred and forty.

03

Artist recruitment and scheduling

Renee recruited and scheduled teaching artists effectively.

04

Relationship building

Families and site partners consistently respond well to Renee.

GROWTH AREAS

01

Budget tracking

Renee needs to keep a closer eye on supply spending. What good looks like: Regular monitoring of supply expenses against budget, with adjustments made before spending gets ahead of plan.

NOTABLE CONTRIBUTIONS

■

Renee wrote the program report for Canvas Kids Arts Collective's biggest grant renewal, which was approved.

Page 2

GOALS

GOAL

HOW WE'LL KNOW

BY

Monitor supply spending closely and stay within budget

Supply expenses tracked regularly and aligned with budget allocations

By the next review

Launch the summer camp program

Summer camp designed, scheduled, and running

Next year

EMPLOYEE COMMENTS

ACKNOWLEDGMENT

Signing confirms this review was shared and discussed. It does not mean the employee agrees with every point.

Employee signature and date

Manager signature and date

How this review was prepared: written from Daniel Ruiz's notes with performerborn, then read, edited and approved by Daniel on October 3, 2026.

Say a few thoughts about each person. We write the review or improvement plan.

About 3 minutes per person, checking included. From $18 per person. Drafted with AI from your notes. You check it and approve it.

Start your reviews