Skip to content

90-day and probation review examples for new hires

By Scott Mackley, founder of performerborn. Updated .

Say a few thoughts about how a new hire is doing: what they’ve picked up, what to work on and what comes next. performerborn writes a finished 30, 60 or 90-day review, or one for the end of a probation period, ready to print and sign. About 3 minutes per person, checking included.

Write mine

From $18 per person, about 3 minutes each

Names and notes are deleted 30 days after your order is finished. Nothing is added beyond what you said.

Page 1 of a sample 30/60/90 day check-in for Tyler Grant, Inside Sales Representative at Summit Clean Supply, written with AI from invented notes
A finished sample review, written with AI from invented notes. See the notes.

90-day review questions

A 90-day review asks two things: what the new hire can now do on their own, and what they still need. Ask yourself these before the meeting:

  • What can they do now without help? What’s one example?
  • What are they still learning, and what would speed it up?
  • How do they work with the team and with customers?
  • What is the one thing to work on next?
  • Are they ready to pass probation, or do you need more time?

Then ask them:

  • Is the job what you expected?
  • What has been harder than you thought?
  • What would help you most in the next few months?

Write their answers down. They belong on the page too.

What to say in a 90-day review

Start with what they picked up, with an example. Then name one thing to work on, and what comes next. Keep it short. New hires remember a review that points to something real.

  • What they picked up. “He’s consistently hitting sixty dials a day.”
  • What to work on. “A few warm leads went cold because he didn’t circle back within the week.”
  • What comes next. “Close three new accounts in the next ninety days.”

Say it in your own words, the way you would to a friend who asked how the new person is doing. performerborn writes it up from that, and adds nothing you didn’t say.

Making an early review useful

  • Name what they can already do, with an example. New hires accept feedback more when it points to something real. How we do this
  • Where a skill is still missing, set a learning goal first: what to learn and by when. Numbers can come later. How we do this
  • Ask how the job is going for them, and listen. Being heard matters to how people take a review. How we do this
  • Keep it about the work, not the person. How we do this

90-day evaluation comments

Good comments describe what you saw, not what kind of person they are. Each one points to a shift, a task or a number. Some you can adapt:

  • “Learned the scheduling system in her first two weeks and now books on her own.”
  • “Customers ask for him by name at the counter.”
  • “Still checks with me on most quotes. By the end of next month, I’d like him handling the common ones alone.”
  • “Shows up early and has the station set before we open.”
  • “Next step: run the Saturday close with a lead for two weeks, then on her own.”

Swap in what you’ve seen. A comment that points to something you saw is easier to accept than “great attitude” or “needs to improve”.

Probation reviews

A probation review is a 90-day review with a decision at the end: the new hire passes probation, or you agree on more time with a date for the next check-in. Say which one in plain words, and why.

  • Passing: “Marcus has passed his ninety days. Next, he takes over renewal reminders.”
  • More time: “We’re adding thirty days to learn the quoting system. We’ll check in again on Nov 14.”

Many small businesses check in at two weeks, around 30 to 45 days, and at 90 days. If the job isn’t working out and you need a formal plan with dates and goals, see improvement plans.

Pick the review

90-day review is one of the choices when you set up your order. For a 30-day, 60-day or probation review, type its name, and add the dates it covers.

The Strengths first design leads with what they do best and what’s next for them. The Quick check-in design fits on one page: what to continue, what to start and what to adjust.

Rather fill it in yourself? Use our free performance review template, as Word or PDF.

Drafted with AI from your notes. You check it and approve it.

A template you can copy

Free template

Free 90-day and probation review template

For a 30, 60 or 90-day review, or the end of a probation period. Most of it is about what they have learned so far and what help they need next.

Prefer a file? The general template is free as Word or PDF, on the template page.

Or have it written from what you say: say a few thoughts about each person, and performerborn writes the finished page for you to check.

New hire review

New hire review

Employee name:
Role:
Start date:
Review date:
End of probation date (if any):

LEARNING THE JOB
What can they now do on their own? Give an example.

What are they still learning? What help would speed it up?

WORKING WITH OTHERS
How do they work with the team and with customers? Give an example.

ONE THING TO WORK ON
What happened, and what would better look like?

QUESTIONS FOR THE NEW HIRE
Is the job what you expected?

What has been harder than expected?

What would help you most?

NEXT 30 TO 90 DAYS
Goal 1. How will you both know it's done? By when?

Goal 2. How will you both know it's done? By when?

NEXT STEP
Probation complete, or the date of the next check-in.

Employee signature and date:

Manager signature and date:

Signing shows this was discussed. It does not mean the employee agrees with every point.

90-day review examples

Each finished review below is exactly what performerborn wrote with AI from the invented notes beside it, unedited. The people and businesses are invented.

30/60/90 day check-in for Tyler Grant, Inside Sales Representative

Commercial cleaning supply · Summit Clean Supply · written with AI from invented notes

What Rob said (94 words)

So Tyler's at about ninety days. Quick check-in. He's been making his calls, he's consistently hitting sixty dials a day, and he booked his first big account last month, a property management company with twelve buildings. He's coachable, he listens to my feedback on calls and actually changes things. Product knowledge is coming along. The thing to work on is follow-up, a few warm leads went cold because he didn't circle back within the week. For the next ninety days I want him to get his CRM notes tight and close three new accounts.

The review shown here is what performerborn wrote with AI from these notes, unedited. The notes are invented, and so are Tyler’s name, the business and the manager.

Page 1 of a sample 30/60/90 day check-in for Tyler Grant, Inside Sales Representative at Summit Clean Supply, written with AI from invented notes
Page 1 of 2.See page 2
Read the text of this review

Page 1

SCS

Summit Clean Supply

30/60/90 DAY CHECK-IN

Check-in

EMPLOYEE

Tyler Grant

ROLE

Inside Sales Representative

MANAGER

Rob Castellano, Sales Manager

REVIEW DATE

October 3, 2026

Tyler has made a solid start in his first ninety days. He is consistent with his outreach, coachable, and closed his first major account. The focus now is tightening his follow-up process and building on that early success.

CONTINUE

Daily outreach Tyler consistently hits sixty dials a day.

Responsiveness to coaching Tyler listens to feedback on calls and makes the changes.

First major account Tyler closed his first big account last month, a property management company with twelve buildings.

START

Timely follow-up Circle back with warm leads within the week so opportunities stay live.

Detailed CRM notes Keep CRM notes current and complete after every call and follow-up.

FOCUS UNTIL NEXT CHECK-IN

Close three new accounts over the next ninety days while keeping follow-up tight and CRM notes current.

Page 2

TYLER'S COMMENTS

Employee signature and date

Manager signature and date

Written from Rob Castellano's notes with performerborn, edited and approved by Rob. Signing confirms it was discussed.

90-day review for Sandra Morales, Warehouse Associate

Fulfillment center · Bayline Fulfillment · written with AI from invented notes

What Chris said (86 words)

Sandra came on as a temp in July and she's been one of our best. Her pick rate is consistently above the target, she hits about a hundred and twenty units an hour, and her accuracy is really high. She learned packing and receiving too, so I can move her wherever. She's positive and easy to work with. What I'd want her to work on is the scanning system shortcuts, she does a lot of things the long way. I'm recommending we bring her on full-time.

The review shown here is what performerborn wrote with AI from these notes, unedited. The notes are invented, and so are Sandra’s name, the business and the manager.

Page 1 of a sample 90-day review for Sandra Morales, Warehouse Associate at Bayline Fulfillment, written with AI from invented notes
Page 1 of 2.See page 2
Read the text of this review

Page 1

BF

Bayline Fulfillment

90-DAY REVIEW

Development Review

EMPLOYEE

Sandra Morales

ROLE

Warehouse Associate

MANAGER

Chris Patton, Shift Supervisor

REVIEW PERIOD

Jul to Sep 2026

REVIEW DATE

October 3, 2026

SUMMARY

Sandra has been one of the best temps since joining in July. She brings a high pick rate, strong accuracy, and the flexibility to work across packing and receiving. The focus for the next period is learning the scanning system shortcuts.

SIGNATURE STRENGTHS

Pick rate and accuracy

Sandra picks at about 120 units an hour, above the target, and her accuracy is high.

Cross-training

Sandra learned packing and receiving in addition to picking.

Working with the team

Sandra keeps a positive tone on the floor and works well with others.

STRETCH AREAS

Scanning system shortcuts

Sandra does many tasks the long way in the scanning system.

What good looks like: Using the shortcuts to move through tasks more quickly.

READY FOR MORE RESPONSIBILITY

Chris is putting Sandra forward for a full-time position based on her first 90 days.

Page 2

DEVELOPMENT PLAN

ACTION

SUPPORT FROM CHRIS

TIMING

Learn the scanning system shortcuts

Over the next few months

SANDRA'S COMMENTS

Employee signature and date

Manager signature and date

Signing confirms this review was shared and discussed, not agreement with every point. Written from Chris Patton's notes with performerborn, then edited and approved by Chris.

90-day review for Jamal Wright, Shift Manager

Fast casual restaurant · Fresh Bowl Kitchen · written with AI from invented notes

What Tara said (87 words)

Jamal's been shift manager for about ninety days and he's settling in well. The crew respects him, he was one of them and he's handled that transition really well. His shifts run smoothly, drive-thru times on his nights are down about forty seconds. He's good at the cash handling and closing. What he's still working on is having tougher conversations, like when someone's late or on their phone, he tends to avoid it. For the next ninety days I want him to start doing short pre-shift huddles.

The review shown here is what performerborn wrote with AI from these notes, unedited. The notes are invented, and so are Jamal’s name, the business and the manager.

Page 1 of a sample 90-day review for Jamal Wright, Shift Manager at Fresh Bowl Kitchen, written with AI from invented notes
Page 1 of 2.See page 2
Read the text of this review

Page 1

FBK

Fresh Bowl Kitchen

90-DAY REVIEW

Development Review

EMPLOYEE

Jamal Wright

ROLE

Shift Manager

MANAGER

Tara Nguyen, General Manager

REVIEW PERIOD

Jul to Sep 2026

REVIEW DATE

October 3, 2026

SUMMARY

Jamal is settling in well as shift manager. He has earned the crew's respect through the transition from team member to supervisor, runs smooth shifts, and handles cash and closing well. The focus for the next ninety days is addressing performance issues in the moment and starting pre-shift huddles.

SIGNATURE STRENGTHS

Transition to supervisor

Jamal made the transition from crew member to shift manager well, and the crew respects him in his new role.

Shift operations

Jamal's shifts run smoothly, and drive-thru times on his nights are down about forty seconds.

Cash handling and closing

Jamal is good at the cash handling and closing procedures.

STRETCH AREAS

Addressing performance issues

Jamal tends to avoid tougher conversations when someone is late or on their phone during a shift.

What good looks like: Address the issue in the moment with a brief, direct conversation.

Page 2

DEVELOPMENT PLAN

ACTION

SUPPORT FROM TARA

TIMING

Start short pre-shift huddles

Starting now

Address lateness and phone use in the moment with brief, direct conversations

Over the next ninety days

JAMAL'S COMMENTS

Employee signature and date

Manager signature and date

Signing confirms this review was shared and discussed, not agreement with every point. Written from Tara Nguyen's notes with performerborn, then edited and approved by Tara.

Say a few thoughts about each person. We write the review or improvement plan.

About 3 minutes per person, checking included. From $18 per person. Drafted with AI from your notes. You check it and approve it.

Start your reviews