Skip to content

How performerborn writes reviews

By Scott Mackley, founder of performerborn. Updated .

performerborn reviews and plans are built on decades of workplace research on feedback people accept and act on. This page sets out the rules the writer follows, in our own words, and how the product keeps to each one.

No study has tested performerborn itself, and we don’t claim it will improve anyone’s performance. What we can say is how the reviews are built: what goes in, what stays out, and what we ask you before we write.

About the work, not the person

Feedback about what someone did gives them something to change. Feedback about who they are tends to make things worse.

How performerborn does it. The writer describes what the person did and what to do next. It never uses labels such as “lazy” or “a natural”, even when your notes do.

Strengths backed by real examples

People accept feedback more when it points to something that really happened.

How performerborn does it. The writer uses the examples you give and never invents one. If your notes have none, a follow-up question asks for one.

A few clear goals, with dates

Clear goals do more than “do your best”, and they work best when people can see their progress. Where a skill is missing, a goal to learn it comes first.

How performerborn does it. Each review ends with a few goals, how progress will show and when, and any help you said you will give.

Room for the employee to respond

Being heard matters to how people take a review, often more than having a say in the result.

How performerborn does it. Each review ends with an employee comments box and signature lines.

Follow-up questions fill the gaps

A useful review needs a few things: an example of something done well, what actually happened with any concern, what comes next, and what good looks like.

How performerborn does it. Before writing, performerborn checks your notes for those four things and asks up to two short questions about whichever are missing. If your notes cover them, it asks nothing. Answering is optional. The questions never ask about health, family, age, religion or anything else private.

Your own words and hedges, kept

A review should sound like the person who wrote it and say no more than they meant.

How performerborn does it. Your dates, numbers and names stay as you said them. If you said something happened “sometimes”, the review says sometimes, not always.

Nothing added beyond your notes

A made-up detail in a review is worse than a short review.

How performerborn does it. The writer works only from what you said and your answers to the follow-up questions. A check after writing looks for anything that isn’t in your notes. Short notes make a short review, on purpose. You read it and approve it before anyone else sees it.

How improvement plans are built

An improvement plan is a plan, not a write-up or a warning. It is meant to help someone get back on track, and it follows the same rules as a review: the work, not the person; your examples; a few clear goals; room to respond. Each plan has five parts.

  1. The standard. What good work looks like in the role, in plain words.
  2. Dated examples. What happened and when, from your notes. Never the person's character.
  3. Goals. Up to three, each with a date, so they don't pull against each other.
  4. Support. The help you say you will give, such as training, a checklist or time with you. Nothing you didn't offer.
  5. Check-ins. When you said you will meet to look at progress, and the end date. Plans run 30, 60 or 90 days; 60 is the default. If your notes give no check-ins or support, the plan adds none and asks you to fill them in before you approve.

You also get a one-page manager guide for the meeting, as its own PDF. It tells you to ask for their view and listen before you finalize anything, and the plan has a section for their comments. Plans are never emailed to employees; you hand them over in person. More about plans.

What stays out

A review or plan is about the work, so health, leave and family stay out. If your notes for an improvement plan mention health, leave or a complaint, it stays out of the plan and you get a private note suggesting advice first.

performerborn is not a law firm and nothing here is legal advice. If you are thinking about letting someone go, or the person has recently taken leave, asked for an accommodation or made a complaint, talk to an employment attorney first.

Sales reviews

People need to see where they stand against their goal, so a sales review puts the goal, the result and the percent of goal side by side in a table. Results alone don’t say what to do next, so the table is followed by what the person did: the calls, the follow-up, the habits to keep or change. Then next period’s number, and a skill to build where one is missing. Pay and commission stay out of the review. More about sales reviews.

How long it takes

“About 3 minutes per person, checking included” and “about 5 minutes per plan” are our own measurements from sample runs. Here is how we got them.

Typical time for one review, step by step
StepTypical
Talk about the person94 words, the typical length of our 212 sample notes, at 150 words a minute38 seconds
Answer up to two follow-up questions40 words at the same pace (an allowance, not yet measured)16 seconds
Your words turned into text24 timed runs5 seconds
Follow-up questions appear62 timed runs2 seconds
We write the review63 timed runs20 seconds
You check it198 words, the typical length of our 212 sample reviews, at 238 words a minute50 seconds
TotalAbout 2.2 minutes
  • Talking: we used 150 words a minute, slower than most people talk, so the estimate errs on the long side.
  • Checking: we used 238 words a minute, a typical silent reading pace.
  • Waiting: the times for turning words into text, the follow-up questions and the writing come from our own server logs between 2 and 5 October 2026.
  • Of our 212 sample reviews, 210 came in under 3 minutes even with slower than usual waits; the longest took 3.3 minutes. For plans, the typical time was 3.3 minutes and all 12 samples were under 5.
  • What it leaves out: any changes you choose to make, which is why we say checking included, not editing included. These are test and sample runs, not timings from customers yet. We will measure again once real orders come in.

Say a few thoughts about each person. We write the review or improvement plan.

About 3 minutes per person, checking included. From $18 per person. Drafted with AI from your notes. You check it and approve it.

Start your reviews