Skip to content

Restaurant and cafe employee evaluations

By Scott Mackley, founder of performerborn. Updated .

A restaurant employee evaluation says how each person is doing on the floor or on the line, one thing to work on, and what’s next. Say a few thoughts about each server, host, cook or barista, and performerborn writes the finished evaluation, ready to print and sign. About 3 minutes per person, checking included.

Write mine

From $18 per person, about 3 minutes each

Names and notes are deleted 30 days after your order is finished. Nothing is added beyond what you said.

Page 1 of a sample improvement plan for Alyssa Moreno, Barista at Juniper Street Coffee, written with AI from invented notes
A finished sample plan, written with AI from invented notes. See the notes.

What should a restaurant evaluation cover?

The same three things for everyone, in the words of their job:

  • What they do well, with an example from a real shift. “Handles a six table section on Friday nights.”
  • One thing to work on, and what happened. “Side work at close gets left for the morning crew.”
  • What’s next. “Start training new servers.”

Front of house: servers, hosts, bartenders, baristas

Guests, speed in a rush, knowing the menu, sales such as wine or desserts, side work, and helping teammates. If you track a number, like check averages or drink times, say it and it goes in as you said it.

Kitchen: line cooks, prep cooks, dishwashers

Ticket times, plates that look the same every time, a clean station, prep finished before service, and labeling and dating. Say what you’ve seen on busy nights and quiet ones.

Making it useful

  • Name a shift. “Kept up with eight tables on Sunday morning” is easier to accept than “great server”. How we do this
  • Say what happened, not what kind of person they are. “Side work at close gets left half done”, not “lazy”. How we do this
  • Agree one clear next step with a date: a new station, training new hires, a checklist finished each close. How we do this
  • Ask for their side before you sign. Being heard matters to how people take a review. How we do this

Rather fill it in yourself? Use our free performance review template, as Word or PDF.

A template you can copy

Free template

Free restaurant and cafe evaluation template

For servers, hosts, bartenders, baristas and kitchen staff. Answer the questions that fit the job and skip the rest.

Prefer a file? The general template is free as Word or PDF, on the template page.

Or have it written from what you say: say a few thoughts about each person, and performerborn writes the finished page for you to check.

Employee evaluation

Employee evaluation

Name:
Position (front of house or kitchen):
Shifts per week:
Evaluation period:
Evaluated by:

DURING A RUSH
What do they do well when it's busy? Name a shift.

GUESTS OR TICKETS
Front of house: how do guests respond to them? Any sales you track?

Kitchen: ticket times, plates, station during service?

OPENING, CLOSING AND SIDE WORK
What gets done, and what gets left for the next shift?

FOOD SAFETY
Labeling, dating, temp logs and a clean station: how are they?

TEAM
Who do they help or train?

ONE THING TO WORK ON
What happened, and what would better look like?

NEXT
A new station, training others, a shift lead role, or something else?

EMPLOYEE COMMENTS
Anything they would like to add.

Employee signature and date:

Manager signature and date:

Signing shows this was discussed. It does not mean the employee agrees with every point.

How often should restaurants do evaluations?

A common rhythm is a review at 90 days, then every six months or once a year. With high turnover, a short evaluation at 90 days catches problems early and tells good new hires they’re seen. See 90-day reviews.

Sample evaluations

Each one was written with AI by performerborn from invented notes, unedited.

Annual review for Brenda Walsh, Server

Family restaurant · Sunny Side Family Diner · written with AI from invented notes

What George said (100 words)

Brenda's been with us a long time and she's still one of the best servers we've got. Families love her, she's great with kids, always has crayons and a joke ready. She can handle a big section on Sunday mornings, eight tables at once, and nobody waits long for coffee. She's also the one who trains our new servers and they all learn the right way. The thing to work on is using the new handheld ordering, she still writes tickets on paper sometimes and it slows the kitchen. Next year I'd like her to help with our weekend scheduling.

The review shown here is what performerborn wrote with AI from these notes, unedited. The notes are invented, and so are Brenda’s name, the business and the manager.

Page 1 of a sample annual review for Brenda Walsh, Server at Sunny Side Family Diner, written with AI from invented notes
Page 1 of 2.See page 2
Read the text of this review

Page 1

SSF

Sunny Side Family Diner

ANNUAL REVIEW

Performance Review

EMPLOYEE

Brenda Walsh

ROLE

Server

MANAGER

George Petrakis, Owner

REVIEW PERIOD

2026

REVIEW DATE

October 3, 2026

OVERALL SUMMARY

Brenda is one of the best servers at Sunny Side Family Diner. She excels with families and children, manages high-volume shifts with ease, and trains new servers to the restaurant's standards. The main area to develop is consistent use of the handheld ordering system.

KEY STRENGTHS

01

Service to families

Brenda is great with families and children, keeping crayons and jokes ready to make their experience welcoming.

02

High-volume service

Brenda handles large sections during busy Sunday mornings, managing up to eight tables at once while keeping wait times short.

03

Training new servers

Brenda trains new servers and ensures they learn the restaurant's standards and procedures correctly.

GROWTH AREAS

01

Handheld ordering system

Brenda sometimes writes tickets on paper instead of using the handheld ordering system, which slows down the kitchen. What good looks like: Use the handheld ordering system for every order to keep the kitchen running smoothly.

Page 2

GOALS

GOAL

HOW WE'LL KNOW

BY

Use the handheld ordering system consistently for all orders

All orders entered through the handheld, with no paper tickets

By the next review

Assist with weekend scheduling

Taking on scheduling responsibilities as George assigns them

Over the next year

EMPLOYEE COMMENTS

ACKNOWLEDGMENT

Signing confirms this review was shared and discussed. It does not mean the employee agrees with every point.

Employee signature and date

Manager signature and date

How this review was prepared: written from George Petrakis's notes with performerborn, then read, edited and approved by George on October 3, 2026.

Quarterly check-in for Malik Johnson, Line Cook

Gastropub kitchen · The Copper Kettle Pub · written with AI from invented notes

What Chef said (77 words)

Quarterly check-in with Malik. He's been strong on the grill station, ticket times are good and his plates look consistent. On busy Fridays he's been knocking out sixty, seventy covers without falling behind. He's a team player, helps the fry station when they get slammed. The thing I want him to work on is his prep list, he's sometimes short going into service and has to cut things mid-rush. Next quarter, I'd like him to learn sauté.

The review shown here is what performerborn wrote with AI from these notes, unedited. The notes are invented, and so are Malik’s name, the business and the manager.

Page 1 of a sample quarterly check-in for Malik Johnson, Line Cook at The Copper Kettle Pub, written with AI from invented notes
Page 1 of 2.See page 2
Read the text of this review

Page 1

CKP

The Copper Kettle Pub

QUARTERLY CHECK-IN

Check-in

EMPLOYEE

Malik Johnson

ROLE

Line Cook

MANAGER

Chef Ryan Doyle, Kitchen Manager

REVIEW DATE

October 3, 2026

Malik has been strong on the grill station this quarter, with good ticket times and consistent plates. He handles high-volume Friday service well and supports the team when needed. The main area to develop is completing prep before service begins.

CONTINUE

Grill station performance Malik keeps good ticket times and his plates look consistent.

High-volume service On busy Fridays, Malik handles about sixty to seventy covers without falling behind.

Supporting the team Malik helps the fry station when they get slammed.

ADJUST

Prep completion Malik is sometimes short on prep going into service and has to cut things mid-rush. Complete the full prep list before service starts each shift.

FOCUS UNTIL NEXT CHECK-IN

Complete all prep before service begins and start learning sauté next quarter.

Page 2

MALIK'S COMMENTS

Employee signature and date

Manager signature and date

Written from Chef Ryan Doyle's notes with performerborn, edited and approved by Chef. Signing confirms it was discussed.

Improvement plan for Alyssa Moreno, Barista

Coffee shop · Juniper Street Coffee · written with AI from invented notes

What Ben said (157 words)

This one's narrow, it's just the cash drawer on her closing shifts. Our standard is the drawer counts within two dollars at close. On Sep 6 her drawer was short eighteen dollars, on Sep 13 it was short twenty five, and on Sep 27 short eleven. She's also been counting the drawer alone, and the close procedure says two people count it together and both initial the sheet. I talked with her on Sep 14 and again on Sep 28. I'm not saying anything other than the counts are off and the procedure isn't being followed. What I want for the next thirty days is every closing drawer within two dollars and every count done with a second person and initialed. I'll retrain her on the register and the count procedure on Monday Oct 5, and I'll count the drawer with her at the end of her first three closing shifts. Let's check in Saturdays after close.

The plan shown here is what performerborn wrote with AI from these notes, unedited. The notes are invented, and so are Alyssa’s name, the business and the manager.

Page 1 of a sample improvement plan for Alyssa Moreno, Barista at Juniper Street Coffee, written with AI from invented notes
Page 1 of 3.See page 2See page 3
Read the text of this plan

Page 1

JSC

Juniper Street Coffee

30-DAY PLAN

Performance Improvement Plan

EMPLOYEE

Alyssa Moreno

ROLE

Barista

MANAGER

Ben Hartley, Owner

PLAN DATES

Oct 5 to Nov 3, 2026

DATE ISSUED

Oct 5, 2026

PURPOSE

This plan focuses on cash drawer accuracy and closing procedures. Our goal is to support you in meeting the standards for your closing shifts.

WHERE THINGS STAND

01

Cash drawer accuracy and closing procedures

Your closing drawer has been short on recent shifts, and the drawer has been counted alone rather than with a second person as the procedure requires. Our standard is that the drawer counts within two dollars at close and that two people count it together and both initial the sheet.

Sep 6: drawer short eighteen dollars

Sep 13: drawer short twenty five dollars

Sep 27: drawer short eleven dollars

EARLIER CONVERSATIONS

■

Sep 14: we talked about cash drawer accuracy and closing procedures

■

Sep 28: we talked about cash drawer accuracy and closing procedures

WHAT SUCCESS LOOKS LIKE

GOAL

HOW WE'LL MEASURE IT

BY

Count every closing drawer within two dollars and complete every count with a second person, with both signatures on the sheet

Every closing drawer within two dollars and every count completed with a second person and initialed

End of plan (Nov 3)

SUPPORT WE WILL PROVIDE

■

Ben will retrain you on the register and the count procedure on Monday, Oct 5

Page 2

■

Ben will count the drawer with you at the end of your first three closing shifts

CHECK-IN SCHEDULE

WHEN

WHAT WE WILL LOOK AT

Weekly, Saturdays after close

Cash drawer accuracy and closing procedures

SUMMARY FOR YOU

PLAN DATES

Oct 5 to Nov 3, 2026 (30 days)

YOUR GOAL

Count every closing drawer within two dollars and complete every count with a second person, with both signatures on the sheet, by Nov 3.

CHECK-INS

Weekly, Saturdays after close

YOUR MANAGER

Ben Hartley, Owner

WHAT HAPPENS NEXT

If these goals are not met, next steps may include further corrective action, a change of role or the end of employment.

This plan is not a contract and does not change the at-will nature of your employment or promise employment for any period. Juniper Street Coffee may extend the plan or act before it ends.

Page 3

YOUR COMMENTS

ACKNOWLEDGMENT

My signature confirms that I received this plan and discussed it with my manager. I may add comments above.

Employee signature and date

Manager signature and date

Witness name

Witness signature

Date

If the employee declines to sign, write ‘declined to sign’ and have a witness sign.

What if it isn't working out?

When a conversation hasn’t been enough, a written plan with dates and goals is the next step. The cafe sample above is one. See improvement plans.

Drafted with AI from your notes. You check it and approve it.

Say a few thoughts about each person. We write the review or improvement plan.

About 3 minutes per person, checking included. From $18 per person. Drafted with AI from your notes. You check it and approve it.

Start your reviews